Caleb nodded, as if she’d named something he’d been avoiding. “Fair.” He pointed to a pile of straw in the corner. “Sit, if you’re willing. Or pick up that knife and do what you think you must. I won’t stop you.”
Benita stared at him, then at the knife, then back again. For a moment the barn held its breath. Then she ignored the knife entirely, walked to the straw, and sat with her knees drawn to her chest, posture defensive, like a wall built from bone.
Caleb’s mouth twitched, not quite a smile, more like relief finding a crack to breathe through. He sat again. “Thank you,” he said quietly. “That’s… a start.”
The lantern hissed. Outside, crickets started their relentless song, as if the night itself couldn’t stop talking even when people had to. Caleb looked down at his hands, then up at her. “Ten years ago,” he began, “I had a boy. My only boy. Vincent. Fifteen and already twice as brave as I ever was.”
Benita’s eyes stayed on him now, not soft, not sympathetic, but focused. Listening was not trust. Listening was survival.
Caleb’s voice tightened as if it had to squeeze past something lodged in his chest. “We went into town for supplies. On the way back, men came out of the trees. Highwaymen. Wanted the wagon. Vincent stepped between them and me. He took a knife in the ribs. He died in my arms before we saw our own gate.”
He swallowed, and the sound was ugly. “My wife didn’t survive me after that,” he continued. “Fever took her three years later. The kind you can’t bargain with. Since then, the farm’s been…” He glanced around the barn like the walls might mock him. “A weight. A curse. And a debt.”
Benita shifted slightly, straw crunching. “Debt.”
Caleb nodded. “Colonel Augustus Harrow. Biggest landowner in these parts. Money like river water, always flowing, always taking. He loaned me to plant. But the last harvest was poor. We had bollworms. Drought. Market prices fell like a stone.”
He laughed once, without humor. “I owe him twelve thousand dollars. If I don’t pay by year’s end, he takes Saint Anthony. Everything.”
Benita’s brows drew together. “Why tell me?”
Caleb leaned forward, lantern light cutting his face into sharp planes. “Because Harrow’s got a daughter. Evelyn. Twenty-two. Not like most of them. She rides hard, shoots straight, bets like she’s trying to insult God.”
Read more on the next page ⬇️⬇️⬇️
